Now Your Place: CSEAS >> Article Center >> Academic Research >> Academic Forum >> 正文 Return to the home page
  SC: Online libel law legal Up Hot     ★★★ 【字体:
SC: Online libel law legal
AuthorChristin…    文章CopyFrom    Hits311    UpdateTime2014-2-19    


Only authors of libelous content face penalties



Militants gather in front of the Supreme Court building in Manila on Tuesday to protest against the cybercrime law. INQUIRER PHOTO/NIÑO JESUS ORBETA

MANILA, Philippines—The Supreme Court on Tuesday upheld the constitutionality of a provision in the controversial Cybercrime Prevention Act of 2012 penalizing online libel amid fears it infringed on Internet freedom.

Likewise, the high court endorsed a provision that seeks to penalize authors of libelous online content but not those receiving and reacting to it.

The court, however, struck down a section in the law that allows the Department of Justice (DOJ) to block access to online content.

After more than a year, the high tribunal finally ruled on the constitutionality of certain provisions in the cybercrime law that were raised by 15 petitioners.

The implementation of Republic Act No. 10175, which President Aquino signed into law in September 2012 to fight crimes committed on the Internet, like cybersex and child pornography, had been suspended for over a year.

The law can now be implemented without the provisions that were struck down.

Solicitor General Francis Jardeleza, who was at the high court to attend the last oral arguments on the Disbursement Acceleration Program, refused to comment on the ruling until he has read it.

At a media briefing, Supreme Court spokesman Theodore Te said the tribunal had “partially granted” the relief sought by the petitioners.

Of the 19 questioned provisions, the court declared four unconstitutional: Sections 4(c)(3), which penalizes the posting of unsolicited commercial communications (or spam); Section 12, which authorizes the collection or recording of traffic data in real time; Section 19, which authorizes the DOJ to restrict or block access to suspected computer data; and Section 7 “as far as it authorizes the prosecution of an offender under online libel and libel under the Revised Penal Code (RPC) and also where it pertains to child pornography for being in violation of the prohibition against double jeopardy.”

The court noted that “online libel is admittedly not a new crime but one already punished under Article 353 (which defines libel in the RPC); Section 4(c)(4) (or online libel) merely establishes the use of a computer as another means of publication. For this reason, charging the offender under both laws would be a violation of the guarantee against double jeopardy under Article III Section 27 of the 1987 Constitution,” said the statement released to the media.

Te said the court upheld the constitutionality of online libel as a cyberoffense. It said that online libel was “not unconstitutional with respect to the original author of the post but unconstitutional only when it penalizes those who simply receive the post or react to it.”

Bayan Muna Rep. Neri Colmenares, one of the petitioners, said they would challenge the ruling.

“No one should go to prison just for expressing oneself, especially on the Internet, where people express their frustration with government,” he said.

“Under cybercrime law, tweets, likes, shares, comments crimes. Everyone under surveillance,” activist Vencer Crisostomo said in a tweet.

Also, the court qualified that Section 5 of the law, which penalizes anyone who aids or abets the commission of cybercrimes and anyone who attempts to commit cybercrimes was “not unconstitutional” in connection with the commission of the following: illegal access, illegal interception, data interference, system interference, misuse of devices, cybersquatting, computer-related fraud and identity theft and cybersex.

But this was deemed unconstitutional “only in relation to offenses punished by child pornography and unsolicited commercial communications and online libel.”—With a report from AFP

 Originally posted: 9:09 pm | Tuesday, February 18th, 2014






Tado’s widow has


her hair shaved


In protest to the untimely death in a bus crash of Arvin Jimenez, better known as comedian “Tado” who sported long hair, his widow shaved off her hair Wednesday in front of the terminal of GV Florida Transport Inc. in Sampaloc, Manila.


Estrada, Guingona


trade barbs


It wasn’t my intention to prejudge your case but Ruby Tuason had the goods on you. This, in a nutshell, was Sen. Teofisto “TG” Guingona III’s message on Tuesday to Sen. Jinggoy Estrada who is under investigation for plunder in the Office of the Ombudsman in connection with the P10-billion pork barrel fund scam.



Traffic jam pleas


flood Palace


Malacañang, inundated with appeals from motorists and commuters to address the looming monstrous traffic jams, is looking at schemes that will free up roads of obstructions such as parked vehicles, basketball courts and ambulant vendors during the duration of the construction of two major road projects in Metro Manila.


Smuggled animals


seized in Surigao


Wildlife officers said Wednesday they had seized almost 100 exotic animals and birds, including cockatoos, echidnas and wallabies, that had been smuggled into the Philippines for sale to wealthy collectors.




Sue Gigi Reyes


Senate Majority Leader Alan Peter Cayetano on Tuesday dared Sen. Juan Ponce Enrile to file charges against his former chief of staff, Jessica Lucila “Gigi” Reyes, and deputy chief of staff, Jose Antonio Evangelista, after they were implicated in the P10-billion pork barrel fund scam.



Kin of dismissed


PMA cadet take up


fight online


Relatives of a graduating Philippine Military Academy cadet supposedly dismissed from service for being two minutes late took to social media their complaints against the PMA leadership.



  • Trash talk
  • ‘General Lina’ and a city’s soul
  • Sleeping mats as wall decor


  • Entry of more foreign banks eyed
  • PSEi nears 6,200 level



    Aquino: Still no reports of abused OFWs in Malaysia

    The Philippine government has obtained no evidence on the alleged rights violation committed against Filipinos detained in Malaysia. President Benigno Aquino III said…

    Binay asks Fil-Chi businessmen to help in ‘Yolanda’ rehab

    Vice President Jejomar C. Binay has asked Filipino-Chinese businessmen to help the government fast-track the construction of houses for victims of typhoon “Yolanda…

    Binay graces 60th foundation of UP Prep

    Vice President Jejomar C. Binay graced the 60th Foundation Anniversary of the University of the Philippines Preparatory School Tuesday. Binay is part of…

    New legal team says poor health entitles Arroyo to bail

    Former president and incumbent Pampanga Rep. Gloria Macapagal-Arroyo is too sick to be detained and to escape. This new argument was entered by…

    Groups continue to oppose Anti-cybercrime Law

    Lawyers, activists, media groups and academic institutions opposing the Anti-Cybercrime Law are undeterred despite the Supreme Court’s (SC) affirmation of its constitutionality, particularly…




  • 文章Inputer:egret    Editor:egret 
  • Prev篇文章:

  • Next篇文章:
  • Print】【Close
    Copyright©2014 CSEAS                          webmaster:titicka